Solution By Steps

Step 1: Understanding Procedural Due Process

Procedural due process refers to the legal requirement that the state must follow fair procedures before depriving a person of life, liberty, or property. This typically involves fair hearings and the right to legal representation.

Step 2: Analyzing Each Option

Option A: This involves a law that denies legal counsel to violent criminals. While this might seem justifiable, it violates the principle of due process by denying legal representation.

Option B: This scenario involves a driver not being informed of their right to appeal a traffic ticket, which violates the procedural due process by not providing information about legal recourse.

Option C: This does not involve a violation of procedural due process as the officer’s decision not to issue a ticket does not deprive the man of any legal rights.

Option D: This involves a law that fines publishers, which might be a policy decision but does not inherently violate procedural due process unless the process of enforcement lacks fairness.

Step 3: Identifying the Clear Violation

Among the options, Option B clearly violates procedural due process by not informing the driver of their right to appeal, which is a critical aspect of due process in legal matters.

Final Answer

The scenario that best illustrates a violation of procedural due process is:

B. A driver receives a traffic ticket but is not told that he can appeal it in court.

This scenario is significant as it highlights the importance of informing individuals of their legal rights and avenues for recourse, which is fundamental to maintaining fairness in legal procedures.